There is something remarkably grounding about making a classic butterscotch pie recipe from scratch. It reminds me of lazy Sunday afternoons spent in my grandmother’s sun-drenched kitchen, where the air always smelled of caramelizing sugar and warm butter. Unlike modern desserts that rely on shortcuts, this pie demands a little patience and a lot of love.
I remember standing on a stepping stool, watching the dark brown sugar dissolve into the milk, transforming into a rich, amber liquid. The anticipation of waiting for that custard to thicken was almost unbearable for a sweet-toothed child. That first bite, however, was always worth the wait, with its velvety texture and deep, molasses-rich flavor.
This particular version pays homage to Southern hospitality, channeling the warmth and charm of icons like Dolly herself. It is not just a dessert; it is a slice of history that brings people together around the table. If you enjoy nostalgic treats, you might also love snacking on homemade candied pecans while you wait for the pie to cool.
The magic really happens when you top the warm filling with the meringue. Watching the egg whites fluff up into glossy white peaks feels like a culinary magic trick every time. It is a simple joy that turns a few basic pantry staples into a show-stopping centerpiece.
Why you’ll love this Dolly’s Southern Butterscotch Pie with Butterscotch Pie Recipe
- This butterscotch pie recipe delivers a depth of flavor that store-bought pudding simply cannot replicate.
- The contrast between the flaky, buttery crust and the smooth, dense custard creates a perfect textural experience.
- It uses everyday ingredients you likely already have in your pantry, making it an accessible luxury.
- The airy, toasted meringue adds a lightness that balances the intense richness of the brown sugar filling.
- It is a versatile dessert that feels just as appropriate at a holiday dinner as it does at a summer barbecue.
- Mastering the old-fashioned custard technique will make you feel like an accomplished pastry chef in your own home.
Ingredients
- 1 (9-inch) pre-baked pie shell (butter-based crust)
- 1 1/2 cups dark brown sugar, firmly packed
- 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
- 1 tablespoon cornstarch
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 3 large eggs, separated (yolks for filling, whites for meringue)
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 1 teaspoon alcohol-free vanilla extract
- 1/4 cup granulated white sugar (for meringue)
Directions
Step 1
Begin by preheating your oven to 350°F (175°C). It is crucial that your pie shell is completely baked and cooled before you add the filling to ensure the crust stays flaky. Set the prepared crust on a baking sheet to make it easier to move later.
Step 2
Separate your eggs carefully while they are cold, placing the yolks in one bowl and the whites in a large mixing bowl. Allow the eggs to come to room temperature before you start cooking. This helps the meringue achieve better volume later on.
Step 3
In a medium heavy-bottomed saucepan, combine the firmly packed dark brown sugar, flour, cornstarch, and salt. Use a whisk to break up any hard lumps of sugar. The mixture should look sandy and uniform before you add any liquid.
Step 4
In a separate small bowl, whisk the egg yolks with the whole milk until the mixture is pale and smooth. This step ensures the yolks are broken up fully so they incorporate evenly. Pour this milk mixture gradually into the saucepan with the dry ingredients.
Step 5
Whisk the contents of the saucepan constantly as you pour to prevent flour pockets from forming. Place the pan over medium heat. Keep your whisk moving to ensure the sugar dissolves completely and nothing sticks to the bottom corners of the pan.
Step 6
Cook the mixture, stirring continuously, for about 8 to 10 minutes. You want the liquid to come to a gentle bubble and thicken significantly. It should reach a consistency similar to warm pudding that coats the back of a spoon.
Step 7
Once thickened, remove the saucepan from the heat immediately. Stir in the softened butter and the alcohol-free vanilla extract. Whisk vigorously until the butter melts completely and the custard looks glossy and smooth.
Step 8
Pour the hot butterscotch filling directly into your prepared pie shell. Smooth the top gently with a spatula to create an even surface. It is important to keep the filling hot for the next step.
Step 9
In a strictly clean and dry glass or metal bowl, beat the 3 egg whites on high speed. Continue beating until soft peaks begin to form. The whites should look frothy and white, losing their translucency.
Step 10
Gradually add the 1/4 cup of granulated sugar, just a spoonful at a time, while continuing to beat on high. Continue this process until stiff, glossy peaks form that stand straight up when you lift the beaters. Do not overbeat, or the meringue may become dry and clumpy.
Step 11
Spoon the meringue immediately over the hot custard filling. Use a spatula to spread it to the edges, ensuring it touches the crust all the way around. This “sealing” technique prevents the meringue from shrinking as it bakes.
Step 12
Use the back of your spoon to create decorative swirls and peaks on top of the meringue. Place the pie in the preheated oven. Bake for 10 to 12 minutes, keeping a close eye on the color.
Step 13
Remove the pie when the meringue peaks are a beautiful toasted golden brown. Let the pie cool completely on a wire rack at room temperature. This cooling period is essential for the custard to set properly before slicing.
Variations, pairings, and serving ideas
Variations
If you want to add a deeper savory note to this butterscotch pie recipe, try making a salted caramel version. Simply increase the salt in the filling to one teaspoon and sprinkle a pinch of flaky sea salt over the meringue before baking. The salty kick cuts through the sweetness beautifully.
For those who love texture, consider adding a layer of crunch to the bottom of the pie. You can sprinkle a handful of toasted, chopped pecans onto the bottom of the crust before pouring in the custard. This adds a nutty surprise that complements the brown sugar perfectly.
You can also swap the traditional pastry crust for a graham cracker or gingersnap crust. The spices in gingersnaps, particularly ginger and cinnamon, pair wonderfully with butterscotch. Just ensure the crumb crust is pre-baked slightly so it holds up to the heavy filling.
If you are not a fan of meringue, you can omit the egg white topping entirely. Instead, chill the pie completely and top it with fresh, stabilized whipped cream just before serving. This creates a creamier, lighter finish reminiscent of a butterscotch cream pie.
Pairings
This rich dessert pairs exceptionally well with a hot cup of black coffee or an unsweetened espresso. The bitterness of the coffee balances the intense sweetness of the brown sugar custard. It is a classic diner-style combination that never fails.
For a cold beverage option, serve slices with a tall glass of ice-cold milk. The creamy neutrality of the milk helps cleanse the palate between bites of the rich, sticky filling. It is particularly refreshing if you are serving the pie during warmer months.
Since this dessert is quite heavy, it serves as a perfect ending to a lighter, savory meal. Think along the lines of roasted chicken with herbs or a fresh vegetable salad. Avoid serving it after a heavy, cream-based pasta dish to keep the meal balanced.
If you are hosting a festive gathering, pair this pie with a tart fruit side, like fresh berries. The acidity of raspberries or blackberries offers a bright contrast to the sugary, caramel notes. It also adds a pop of color to the dessert plate.
Serving ideas
Slice this pie only after it has cooled completely to room temperature or has been chilled. If you cut into it while it is warm, the filling may run and lose its shape. Patience is truly the key to that perfect, photogenic slice.
To get the cleanest cuts, dip a sharp chef’s knife into a pitcher of hot water before each slice. Wipe the blade dry with a paper towel between cuts to prevent the meringue from dragging through the custard. This ensures every guest gets a beautiful, layered piece.
Serve each slice on a simple white plate to let the golden colors of the pie shine. You can dust the plate lightly with a little cinnamon or powdered sugar for an elegant touch. A sprig of fresh mint can also add a nice visual contrast.
For an extra indulgent treat, drizzle a tiny bit of warm caramel sauce over the slice right before serving. This reinforces the butterscotch flavor profile. However, use a light hand, as the pie is already quite sweet on its own.
Storage and make-ahead tips
Storage
Because this pie contains milk and eggs, it must be stored in the refrigerator. Leaving it out at room temperature for too long can cause the custard to spoil. Cover the pie loosely with plastic wrap or a pie dome to protect it.
Insert toothpicks into the meringue before covering to keep the plastic from sticking to the topping. Consume the leftovers within 2 to 3 days for the best quality. After this time, the meringue may start to weep or separate from the filling.
Freezing this particular butterscotch pie recipe is not recommended. Meringue tends to become rubbery and weepy when thawed, and the custard can separate. It is a dessert best enjoyed fresh or simply refrigerated.
If you find liquid pooling at the bottom of the pie plate, do not worry; this is natural “weeping.” It does not mean the pie is bad, but it might make the crust a bit soggy. Serve the remaining slices quickly to enjoy the textures before they soften too much.
Make-ahead
You can bake the pie crust up to a day in advance to save time on the day of assembly. Store the baked crust in an airtight container at room temperature until you are ready to make the filling. This breaks up the workload significantly.
While the filling is best made fresh, you can mix the dry ingredients (sugar, flour, starch, salt) a few days ahead. Store this mix in a jar or sealed bag. When you are ready to cook, simply whisk it into the milk as directed.
Do not attempt to make the meringue in advance. Egg whites lose their volume and structure if they sit for too long. Always whip the whites right before the custard finishes cooking on the stove.
For the best results, bake the pie early on the day you plan to serve it. This gives it ample time to cool and set without rushing. Making it the morning of your dinner party is the ideal timing strategy.
Common mistakes when making Dolly’s Southern Butterscotch Pie
- One common error is cooking the custard over heat that is too high, causing the bottom to scorch. Always use medium heat and stir constantly to protect the delicate sugar and milk solids.
- Adding the hot milk to the egg yolks too quickly can scramble the eggs. Pour the milk in a slow, thin stream while whisking the yolks vigorously to temper them properly.
- Failing to seal the meringue to the edge of the crust often results in the topping shrinking away as it cools. Make sure the egg whites touch the pastry crust all around the perimeter.
- Putting the meringue on a cold filling is a recipe for weeping (watery layer). The filling must be piping hot to help cook the underside of the egg whites and create a bond.
- Undercooking the filling will lead to a runny pie that spills out when sliced. Ensure the mixture bubbles and holds the texture of pudding before removing it from the heat.
Final notes
There is a profound sense of satisfaction that comes from mastering a traditional dessert like this. The process of turning sugar, eggs, and milk into a golden masterpiece is a rewarding kitchen adventure. I hope this recipe brings a touch of Southern sweetness to your table.
Remember that the key to a great custard pie is patience, especially during the cooking and cooling stages. Do not rush the thickening process, and definitely do not rush the cooling time. Your patience will be rewarded with clean slices and perfect textures.
I encourage you to share this butterscotch pie recipe with friends and family. It is the kind of dessert that creates memories and starts traditions. Enjoy every velvety, buttery bite!
Loved this Dolly’s Southern Butterscotch Pie? Try these next
- Homemade candied pecans
- Cook Reel Home
- Cherry coconut magic bars
- Corn black bean guacamole
- Explore more recipes
Dolly’s Southern Butterscotch Pie
A nostalgic and deeply comforting dessert featuring a rich, velvety caramelized brown sugar custard poured into a flaky butter crust, crowned with a cloud of golden-toasted meringue. This old-fashioned recipe captures the essence of Southern hospitality.
- Total Time: 45 minutes
- Yield: 8 slices 1x
Ingredients
- 1 (9-inch) pre-baked pie shell (butter-based crust)
- 1 1/2 cups dark brown sugar, firmly packed
- 3 tablespoons all-purpose flour
- 1 tablespoon cornstarch
- 1/2 teaspoon salt
- 3 large eggs, separated (yolks for filling, whites for meringue)
- 2 cups whole milk
- 1/4 cup unsalted butter, softened
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1/4 cup granulated white sugar (for meringue)
Instructions
- Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C). Ensure your pie shell is fully baked and cooled before starting the filling.
- In a medium heavy-bottomed saucepan, whisk together the dark brown sugar, flour, cornstarch, and salt until well combined and free of large lumps.
- In a separate bowl, whisk the egg yolks with the whole milk until smooth. Gradually pour the milk mixture into the saucepan with the dry ingredients, whisking constantly.
- Place the saucepan over medium heat. Cook, stirring continuously to prevent scorching, until the mixture bubbles and thickens into a pudding-like consistency (about 8-10 minutes).
- Remove from heat. Immediately stir in the softened butter and vanilla extract until the butter is fully melted and the filling is glossy. Pour the hot filling into the prepared pie shell.
- In a clean, dry glass or metal bowl, beat the 3 egg whites on high speed until soft peaks form. Gradually add the 1/4 cup granulated sugar a spoonful at a time, beating until stiff, glossy peaks form.
- Spread the meringue over the hot filling, ensuring you seal it all the way to the edges of the crust to prevent shrinking.
- Bake in the preheated oven for 10-12 minutes, or until the meringue peaks are beautifully golden brown. Remove and let cool completely on a wire rack before slicing.
Notes
For the cleanest slices, dip your knife in hot water and wipe it dry between cuts. Ensure the filling is hot when you add the meringue to help cook the underside of the egg whites and prevent ‘weeping’. Store leftovers in the refrigerator.
Nutrition
- Serving Size: 1 slice
- Calories: 410
- Sugar: 45g
- Sodium: 280mg
- Fat: 14g
- Saturated Fat: 7g
- Unsaturated Fat: 6g
- Trans Fat: 0g
- Carbohydrates: 62g
- Fiber: 1g
- Protein: 6g
- Cholesterol: 85mg